Butch Mathenia

We partner with our clients to deliver the most cost-effective, exceptional results on defense and civil litigation matters. Scarborough Attorneys At Law announces Amy McConnell as a new Partner of the firm! Amy brings over nine years of experience litigating in State and Federal courts in both Third- and First-Party Insurance Defense. On December 5, 2023, Butch Mathenia, Esq. of Scarborough Attorneys at Law successfully obtained sanctions against the Plaintiff glass shop and/or their attorney in two separate lawsuits, pursuant to Florida Statute § 57.105(1). On October 11, 2023, Butch Mathenia, Esq. of Scarborough Attorneys at Law obtained a voluntary dismissal in response to the Motion for Summary Judgment that was filed in conjunction with a Motion for Sanctions pursuant to Florida Statute 57.105. On October 9, 2023, Butch Mathenia, Esq. of Scarborough Attorneys at Law obtained dismissals in two separate breach of contract actions on behalf of the Defendant insurer.